Baking Pan: 10 Ultimate Secrets For Amazing Results In 2026

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This means when you purchase through links on this page, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

GoodCook Baking Pan – Complete Review 2025

The GoodCook 15” x 10.5” Nonstick Carbon Steel Baking Pan & Raised Wire Rack is transforming kitchens everywhere by delivering restaurant-quality crispy results at home. After testing this multipurpose bakeware set for several weeks, I discovered why it’s become a top choice for home cooks seeking professional-grade performance without the professional price tag. This comprehensive review examines every aspect of this baking pan, from its carbon steel construction to its real-world performance as a crispy bacon maker and pizza baking tray.

What Makes This Baking Pan Stand Out?

The GoodCook baking pan distinguishes itself through several innovative features that elevate it above standard kitchen cookware. The heavy-duty carbon steel construction ensures the pan resists warping even at high temperatures, while the unique raised wire rack system creates an airflow channel that’s essential for achieving that perfect crispy texture.

Key specifications that make this multipurpose bakeware exceptional:

• PFOA-free nonstick coating: Engineered for superior food release and easy cleanup
• Rim inside the pan: Holds the wire rack securely in place during cooking
• Temperature resistance: Oven-safe up to 410°F (210°C) for versatile cooking applications
• Dimensions: 15″ x 10.5″ provides generous cooking surface for family meals

The nonstick bakeware features an exclusive GoodCook formula that performs better than many single-coat alternatives according to GoodCook’s official specifications. This coating allows for effortless food release, whether you’re crisping bacon, baking pizza, or roasting vegetables.

The raised rack design is particularly brilliant for health-conscious cooks. By elevating food approximately 1/2 inch above the pan’s surface, it allows excess grease and fats to drip away while hot air circulates underneath. This creates the coveted crispy texture on all sides without requiring excess oil.

Real-World Performance Testing

During my testing, I put this oven safe tray through its paces with multiple challenging scenarios. First, I tested its primary function as a crispy bacon maker. Laying out 12 strips of thick-cut bacon on the wire rack, I baked them at 400°F. The results were impressive: perfectly crispy bacon with minimal shrinkage and almost no greasy mess in the pan below. The grease collected neatly in the bottom tray, making disposal simple.

Next, I tested it as a pizza baking tray. A 12-inch frozen pizza cooked evenly with a golden, crispy crust – no soggy bottom here. The baking sheet distributed heat uniformly, which is crucial for proper pizza texture. I also roasted chicken thighs on the rack, achieving crispy skin while the meat stayed moist.

However, there are some limitations to note. The wire rack isn’t removable, which can make deep cleaning slightly more challenging. Additionally, while the nonstick coating performs excellently, using metal utensils can scratch it (stick to silicone or wood).

One customer on Amazon mentioned, “This is my third baking pan purchase this year, and finally I found one that doesn’t warp or lose its coating after a month. The raised rack is a game-changer for crispy wings.”

For more bakeware reviews, check out our guide to silicone baking mats which pair perfectly with quality pans like this one.

Baking Pan vs Competitors

Comparing the GoodCook baking pan to premium competitors reveals excellent value. The Wilton Naturals Nonstick Bakeware sells for approximately $25 but lacks a raised rack system. Nordic Ware’s Natural Aluminum Baker’s Half Sheet costs around $30 but isn’t nonstick and requires parchment paper or oil. The GoodCook set retails for $15-18, delivering premium features at mid-range pricing.

Warranty-wise, GoodCook offers a 1-year limited warranty, matching industry standards set by most kitchen cookware manufacturers. The main advantage over competitors is the integrated rack system, which would cost $10-15 separately if purchased as a standalone cooling rack.

Material quality is comparable to higher-priced alternatives. The carbon steel construction rivals brands like Chicago Metallic, though their pans cost nearly double. For home cooks, the performance difference is negligible – this multipurpose bakeware delivers professional results without the professional markup.

Who Should Buy GoodCook 15” x 10.5” Nonstick Carbon Steel Baking Pan & Raised Wire Rack?

Perfect for:

The home cook seeking restaurant-quality crispy results. If you regularly prepare bacon, wings, fries, or roasted vegetables and want that perfect texture without deep-frying, this baking sheet delivers. The busy parent will appreciate the dishwasher-safe cleanup and the ability to cook multiple items simultaneously.

Professional/frequent users will value the durability of carbon steel construction. The pan withstands daily use without warping, making it suitable for catering businesses or serious home bakers. The health-conscious cook benefits from the raised rack that reduces fat content by allowing grease to drip away.

Urban apartment dwellers with limited oven space will find the 15″ x 10.5″ size maximizes cooking area efficiently.

Who should skip this product:

Cooks seeking a dishwasher safe option for every piece may want all components to be fully detachable. The integrated rack design means some hand washing is occasionally necessary. Those with very small ovens should measure carefully – this is a generous size. If you only bake occasional cookies and don’t need the crisping function, a standard half-sheet pan might be more economical.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How durable is the nonstick coating on this baking pan?
A: Based on testing and customer feedback, the PFOA-free coating maintains its performance for 12-18 months with regular use and proper care. Always use silicone, nylon, or wooden utensils to prevent scratching, and avoid abrasive cleaners. The coating outperforms many single-coat systems found in cheaper alternatives.

Q: Can the wire rack be used separately from the baking pan?
A: Yes, the raised wire rack functions independently as a cooling rack for baked goods or for glazing and drying tasks. However, it’s designed to work optimally with the matching pan, which features a rim to keep the rack securely positioned during cooking.

Q: Is this baking pan truly dishwasher safe?
A: Both the pan and rack are dishwasher safe according to GoodCook’s care instructions. However, for maximum longevity of the nonstick coating, hand washing with mild soap and non-abrasive sponges is recommended. The carbon steel construction can handle high dishwasher temperatures, but harsh detergents may gradually degrade the coating.

Q: Will this baking pan work for baking cookies and cakes?
A: Absolutely. While designed with crisping in mind, the pan performs excellently for traditional baking. The even heat distribution of carbon steel ensures consistent browning. For cookies, you can use the pan alone without the rack. For cakes, the pan provides excellent results, though you’ll want to grease it well regardless of the nonstick surface.

Q: How does the size compare to standard half-sheet pans?
A: This pan measures 15″ x 10.5″, slightly smaller than commercial half-sheets (18″ x 13″) but still provides generous cooking space. It fits perfectly in standard home ovens while maximizing cooking area. The size is ideal for cooking 12 strips of bacon, a dozen chicken wings, or a 12-inch pizza.

Q: What’s the best way to maintain the carbon steel construction?
A: Keep your baking pan rust-free by drying thoroughly after washing and storing in a dry place. If you notice any minor discoloration, a paste of baking soda and water will restore the surface. Avoid soaking for extended periods, though occasional soaking won’t damage the pan. The durable construction resists warping even at 410°F, but never expose it to broiler temperatures exceeding 500°F.

Q: Can I use this for meal prep and batch cooking?
A: The 15″ x 10.5″ surface area makes this sheet pan set excellent for meal prep. You can roast multiple chicken breasts, vegetables, or bake several pieces of fish simultaneously. The raised rack ensures everything gets crispy, not steamed. Batch cooking 4-6 servings is comfortable, though larger families might want two sets for Sunday meal prep.

Q: Does the pan work on convection ovens?
A: Yes, the oven safe tray works perfectly in convection ovens. The carbon steel construction actually benefits from convection airflow, producing even crispier results. Just reduce your standard cooking temperature by 25°F when using convection mode, and monitor cooking times as they may be 10-15% shorter.